East Africa: 'New trade deal between EAC and US good, but who cares?'

East Africa: 'New trade deal between EAC and US good, but who cares?'
Published date:
Monday, 23 July 2012
Author:
Rwanda Focus (Kigali)

The USA is proposing a new trade arrangement with East Africa even as the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), enacted in 2000, remains in force.

Commerce is arguably the most ancient and effective tool in the fight against poverty and development of infrastructure. It is early trade links between Africa and the outside world that explains the development of cities such as Mombasa and Dar ess Salaam and the subsequent opening up of the interior through roads and railway. That is why a proposal by US President Barrack Obama's administration for a separate trade deal with East Africa (Burundi, Kenya, Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda) sounds very good. However, that is just how far it can go.

When former US President Bill Clinton signed AGOA into law in 2000, it opened up the American market to about 40 beneficiary countries in sub-Saharan Africa to export thousands of different types of goods to the world's largest economy, quota and duty free.

This arrangement was later expanded to include more goods and extended up to 2015. It was and still remains the best opportunity ever for poor countries to access a lucrative market such as the United States without restrictions.

However, 12 years since the Americans extended this generous offer, US imports from Africa under AGOA are being dominated by oil--the most sought after commodity in the world that the Americans keep buying to build their own reserves.

That is why eligible AGOA countries that are oil producers such as Angola, Gabon, Nigeria have pocketed virtually all the dollars that Americans have had to pay for imports under this trade arrangement. What this means is that AGOA beneficiary countries, that include all EAC-member countries, have largely failed to build capacity to tap into this very lucrative market.

With the exception of Lesotho that has done well in exporting apparel, Kenya with its cut flowers, and Mauritius that is excelling in the export of prepared seafood, non-oil export opportunities to the US remain largely unexploited.

The failure to expand opportunities for agricultural products such as apparel, beef, milk, chicken, tropical fruits (bananas, mangoes pineapples, oranges etc) means rural people who are the poorest of the poor, cannot access the opportunities presented by AGOA. And because they are the majority, it is very safe to conclude that AGOA has not achieved its intended objective of turning poor Africans from aid recipients to trade partners with the west.

Take for example cotton, one of the easiest and environmentally friendly crops to grow that most countries in Africa such as Uganda were in the past known for. By the time Americans opened their market to cotton products from Africa under AGOA, Uganda cotton farmers had virtually given up on the crop whose price was dictated by processors in East Asia.

Remember that Uganda had a vibrant cotton industry with ginning, spinning and weaving facilities that made finished products until the 1980s when the industry that employed millions of people collapsed.

Many Ugandans thought that the coming of AGOA would provide incentive for the government to rehabilitate this decaying cotton infrastructure that would encourage farmers to grow more cotton to provide a raw material to make apparel for export to the US.

Instead, the government invested in a company that imported semi-finished products from the far-east to stitch into garments in Kampala for export to the US as "Made in Uganda." Yet the semi-finished imports from Asia are from the very grown in Uganda and exported raw.

When the grace period for which America would allow Uganda to use cotton products from Asia expired, Apparel Tristar, the phony company on which the country stake in AGOA hinged on, closed shop. That was the end of the story and Uganda cotton farmers continue to export jobs meant for their children to Europe and the Middle East in form of unprocessed cotton.

Unless EAC comes up with a detailed program on how to enable local people to produce for the market, even the new trade deal the Obama is proposing will fall flat just like AGOA that his fellow democrat, Bill Clinton, championed.

While I would not like to indulge in speculate, the five-nation EAC with 130 million consumers, confirmed commercial oil and gas deposits is certainly a good partner to trade with for foresighted country that US is.

Share this article

View related news articles

Africa seeks bigger US trade slice for AGOA to make sense

African countries may need more trade privileges with the US even as Washington reviews the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) meant to expand what the continent will export. At the end of the US-Africa summit in December, Washington pledged to renew Agoa, bringing clarity to uncertainties that had befell exporters from countries such as Kenya. But now experts say the narrow view of Agoa should be expanded to allow them to export more...

11 January 2023

EAC States challenged on trade agreements

The East African Community (EAC) partner states have been challenged to increase their volume of transactions under regional and international trade agreements. The region’s private sector trade block, East Africa Business Council, said it is imperative for the region to take advantage of opportunities such as the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA), African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), Economic partnership agreement, to...

23 August 2022

Rwanda eyes stronger ties with Biden Administration

The Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation, Vincent Biruta, has said that Rwanda is ready to strengthen ties with the administration of the new President of the United States, Joe Biden. Biden was sworn-in on January 20, becoming the 46th President of the US. "We are ready to continue working with the new administration in strengthening existing relations between our two countries including levelling up existing...

25 January 2021

Kenya, Ethiopia ahead of region in benefits of AGOA treaty

Kenya led the East African Community members in its use of the Africa Growth Opportunity Act (Agoa) treaty, scoring 98 per cent. However, it came second to Ghana which recorded 99.1 per cent with Madagascar coming third at 93.7 per cent. According to data contained in the US Trade and Investment with sub-Saharan Africa: Recent Trends and New Developments report, Ethiopia at 81.9 per cent and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC)...

26 May 2020

Report calls for joint marketing of EAC as investment destination and eradication of NTBs

A report of the recently concluded high level conference on trade integration notes that there is a downward trend on the profile of the East African Community (EAC) as an attractive investment destination. The report calls for the EAC Partner States to market EAC jointly, further consolidate free trade by eliminating individual State exemption lists, liberalize and allow free movement of trade and services, eradicate non-tariff barriers...

28 September 2019

East Africa exports to the US hit $1bn in the year to September 2018

Exports from East African countries to the US reached about $1 billion between October 2017 and September 2018, a 17 per cent increase from the same period the previous year. The United States Agency for International Development’s East Africa Trade and Investment Hub said apparel dominated the region’s sales at 84.4 per cent of exports. The Africa Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) gives sub-Saharan Africa duty-free access to US markets...

31 December 2018

'Here's why the used clothing trade deserves more attention'

While friction over the ban of used clothing exports from the US to East Africa seems to have come to an end, some fundamental issues still remain, according to Shannon Brady and Sheng Lu from the University of Delaware. Their latest research throws up complex economic, social, legal and political factors linked with the trade in second-hand clothes and questions the effectiveness of preference programmes such as AGOA as a tool for economic...

11 December 2018

Hello, America! USAID, direct flights to increase AGOA exports to US

The US Agency for International Development (USAID) Hub will from November 2018 to March 2019 provide direct support in the audit and Worldwide Responsible Accredited Production (WRAP) certification process. Already, USAID is helping companies in the East African region become more export competitive. WRAP is a minimum standard for social compliance where US textile and apparel buyers procure products from ethical and socially compliant...

19 October 2018

East Africa debate: Suspension of Rwanda’s AGOA benefits – What does it mean? [Video]

Barely weeks after the Trump administration partially suspended Rwanda’s benefits to export apparel duty-free to the US under the African Growth and Opportunity Act - AGOA, the government of Rwanda says that it remains committed to supporting any Rwandan trader who still wishes to access the US market. The government also says that it expects minimal effects from the suspension. Just what does this suspension mean?

22 August 2018

'Rwanda AGOA limitations signals era of reciprocal trading'

Last week, the Trump administration announced the withdrawal of benefits for Rwanda to export apparel duty-free to the US under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa). This is largely seen as a response to Kigali’s decision to ban second-hand clothes in its market. However, there is a larger trend at play here. We are in an era of trade wars and serious global disagreements as to what is deemed fair, or not, in trade practice and...

05 August 2018

Presidential Proclamation regarding Rwanda's AGOA eligibility

  Presidential Proclamation to Take Certain Actions Under the African Growth and Opportunity Act and For Other Purposes  Issued on: July 30, 2018 1.  In Proclamation 7350 of October 2, 2000, the President designated the Republic of Rwanda (“Rwanda”) as a beneficiary sub-Saharan African country for purposes of section 506A(a)(1) of the Trade Act of 1974 (the “1974 Act”) (19 U.S.C. 2466a(a)(1)),...

31 July 2018