'Trump effect on Africa'

'Trump effect on Africa'
Published
Thursday, 17 November 2016 ~ Kathy Davy

We can only speculate as to what extent the Donald Trump administration could affect the African continent. However, we believe the two main areas of concern based on Trump’s election rhetoric are foreign trade and US foreign assistance (US aid). Trump has openly voiced his unhappiness with both overseas aid and existing trade deals.

Could AGOA be cancelled under Trump?

Although vocal on existing trade deals, Trump has mentioned very little with respect to his stance on trade with Africa. Perhaps this is because in 2015, non-oil and gas trade into the US under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) was only around US$4.5bn, representing just 2% of the United States’ total global trade and hence very insignificant for the country. 

AGOA is a trade agreement with the US which allows 38 eligible sub-Saharan African countries to export thousands of different products to the US duty-free. This treaty was recently renewed and expires in 2025. Trump’s concern with US trade deals is rooted in the notion that these deals may be detrimental to American jobs. However, it’s not generally thought that AGOA has led to any significant jobs losses in the US and the agreement has not been a focus of lobbying groups. 

Although Africa previously had a trade surplus with the US under AGOA, as a result of declining oil prices and falling oil and gas products exported to the US from Africa, the trade gap has closed significantly as illustrated in Figure 1. The trade balance is now only slightly weighted in favour of AGOA countries.  

Figure 1

2016 11 17 trump agoa fig 1

Source: AGOA.info

 

Our view is therefore that it is very unlikely that AGOA will be cancelled under a Trump administration as there would be little direct benefit for the US in doing so.  On the other hand, the AGOA treaty is very beneficial to sub-Saharan Africa with the leading exporters to the US illustrated in Figure 2. In the event that trade under AGOA is reduced, it could be argued that this would incentivise increased intra-Africa trade which would be very positive for the continent as a whole. 

 

Figure 2

2016 11 17 trump agoa fig 2

Source: AGOA.info

 

Removal/reduction of US foreign assistance to Africa (US aid)

The US intends to spend a total of US$34bn on foreign assistance in FY2017 of which 21% is planned to go to Africa. This is 0.2% of the FY2017 US budget which means any removal or reduction of aid to Africa would save the US very little should Trump decide to target this expenditure. In addition, part of this foreign assistance supports US business. For example, Egypt receives US$1.5bn in foreign assistance of which 90% is spent on ‘Peace and Security’ where Egypt’s military equipment is largely bought from the US. 

US aid means far more for Africa than it does for the US. The following table illustrates foreign assistance for 2016 as a percentage of government consumption for some large African countries as well as the key budgetary areas that it is destined for. 

 

Figure 3

2016 11 17 trump agoa fig 3

Source: Economic Intelligence Unit, foreignassistance.gov

The concern is that Trump has in the past tweeted his disapproval of the foreign assistance US sends to Africa as illustrated:

His view may be changing however. At a rally in New Hampshire, Trump was asked whether he would double the number of people receiving AIDS/HIV treatment by 2020 to which he replied: “Yes, I believe so strongly in that, and we’re going to lead the way”. PEPFAR (The United States President’s Emergency Plan for Aids Relief) forms part of the foreign assistance which the US supplies to Africa.  

This suggests that a Trump presidency will still support certain types of aid such as health which makes up a large portion of Africa’s financial assistance from the US as shown in Figure 3. In addition, although foreign assistance does not always get directed in the best possible direction and could also fall foul of corruption, financial aid has evolved from direct budgetary support to specific projects which has resulted in increased accountability.

We therefore believe US aid to Africa will continue, although a gradual reduction in Africa’s dependence on US foreign assistance would most likely be positive for the continent over the longer-term.

In conclusion, although Donald Trump has been vocal in his disapproval of trade treaties and US aid, we believe that the benefits to the US of removing or reducing those related to Africa are so small that the status quo is likely to be largely maintained.

View related news articles

Fact sheet: The President’s trade agenda and annual report

On March 1, 2019, the United States Trade Representative released President Trump’s 2019 Trade Policy Agenda and Annual Report, outlining how the Administration’s trade policies are benefitting American workers, contributing to the strongest U.S. economy in decades, and rebalancing America’s trade relationships and the global economy. In just two years, the Administration has already made significant progress in implementing its trade...

01 March 2019

'Trump’s Africa surprise'

Africa has generally ranked near the bottom of US foreign policy priorities. Historically, two-term presidents have waited until their second term to establish their legacies on the continent, and many one-term presidents have neglected it altogether. US President Donald J. Trump has surprised many by bucking this trend.  In December, US National Security Advisor John Bolton unveiled a formal strategy for...

04 February 2019

The Trump administration’s Africa strategy: Primacy or partnership?

Last week, the Trump administration launched an Africa policy that seeks both primacy and partnership on the continent. The administration’s efforts at partnership, especially as it relates to promoting U.S. business on the continent, are likely to be far more lasting and consequential. Ambassador John Bolton set the tone for the administration in a speech where he challenged African governments to choose the United States over...

20 December 2018

Advisor Ambassador John Bolton on the the Trump administration’s new Africa strategy

As delivered on December 13, 2018. Heritage Foundation, Washington, D.C. Well, Kim, thanks very much, and thanks to you and Kay for inviting me here. I’m delighted again to be here at the Heritage, an institution that really has contributed so much to the public policy debate for many decades now in the United States. And I’m particularly pleased to be here to unveil the Trump administration’s new Africa Strategy, which the President...

13 December 2018

President Trump’s Africa strategy advances prosperity, security, and stability [incl. Factsheet]

Remarks by National Security Advisor Ambassador John R. Bolton on the Trump Administration’s New Africa Strategy I’m delighted again to be here at the Heritage, an institution that really has contributed so much to the public policy debate for many decades now in the United States. And I’m particularly pleased to be here to unveil the Trump administration’s new Africa Strategy, which the President approved yesterday, and which the...

13 December 2018

'Protecting South Africa from US anti-trade action'

South Africa may well be a “non-combatant” and an “innocent bystander” in the economic warfare which US President Donald Trump has launched against America’s major economic rivals, as trade and industry minister Rob Davies has frequently complained.  But it can and should act at least to mitigate the fallout from the gathering global contest, which now also involves Iran.    Six months ago Davies first complained...

20 September 2018

Kenya: Foreign Affairs Secretary meets ambassadors in the US ahead of Kenyatta-Trump meeting

Foreign Affairs Cabinet Secretary Monica Juma is already in the United States ahead of a scheduled visit to the White House by President Uhuru Kenyatta on Monday. Upon her arrival at the Dulles International Airport on Wednesday, the CS held talks with 28 African resident ambassadors on trade cooperation with the US post-African Growth and Opportunity Act framework (AGOA). She also engaged the ambassadors on the African Continental Free...

24 August 2018

'Trump’s trade action may benefit Africa'

Opinion Piece: The Donald Trump presidency is fast changing almost everything about the US’s role in the world and how the world is managed. No one seems to be spared from its ruthless pursuit of narrow nationalist interests. The recent decision to suspend Rwanda’s right to export duty-free to the US under the African Growth and Opportunities Act (Agoa) is meant to stop Rwanda from increasing tariffs imposed on used clothing and footwear...

05 August 2018

'Trump’s Africa policy is a continuation of Clinton’s, Bush’s, and Obama’s'

President Trump’s Africa policy appears to be off to a bad start. First, there was the unfortunate leak of a remark made privately to a group of U.S. senators in February in which the President referred to African nations as “shithole countries.” Secondly, former Secretary of State Rex Tillerson’s official goodwill visit to several African countries in March was spoiled by the fact that he had to cut his visit short by one day...

23 April 2018

President Trump updates trade preference program eligibility for Rwanda

The President determined today the eligibility of Rwanda, Tanzania, and Uganda for trade preference benefits under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). In response to a petition filed by the U.S. used clothing industry in March 2017, the Administration initiated an out-of-cycle review of Rwanda, Tanzania, and Uganda’s AGOA eligibility regarding their decisions to phase in a ban on imports of used clothing and footwear.  The...

29 March 2018

Presidential proclamation on adjusting imports of steel into the United States

1. On January 11, 2018, the Secretary of Commerce (Secretary) transmitted to me a report on his investigation into the effect of imports of steel mill articles (steel articles) on the national security of the United States under section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, as amended (19 U.S.C. 1862). 2. The Secretary found and advised me of his opinion that steel articles are being imported into the United States in such quantities and...

08 March 2018