South Africa, US narrow meat import differences
South Africa and the United States are painstakingly inching towards a resolution of their protracted trade dispute over US meat imports which is threatening South Africa’s access to the US market.
But the government’s draft legislation to force foreigners to sell off their majority shares in private security companies is now posing a bigger threat to South Africa’s continued participation in the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) and even to potential loans from the World Bank and International Monetary Fund.
On Monday economist Roelof Botha of the Gordon Institute of Business Science (BIGS) said at the South African Chamber of Commerce and Industry (SACCI) in Johannesburg that the security legislation could knock R133,4 billion off South Africa’s GDP, R52 billion off tax revenue and cost about 850,000 formal and informal jobs.
Those would be the effects of the act discouraging foreign investment, losing South Africa’s duty-free access to the lucrative US market through Agoa and likely provoking trade retaliation from US and European countries.
The Private Security Industry Regulation Amendment Act has been passed by both houses of Parliament but it has been sitting on President Jacob Zuma’s desk unsigned for seven months because of the huge controversy surrounding its Section 20 (d).
That would force foreign private security firms to sell at least 51 percent of their firms to South Africans. Pretoria says foreign ownership is a threat to national security, a claim the firms scoff at.
US officials have warned that if Section 20(d) is not removed, the US government would very likely deem that South Africa is expropriating US property.
That would automatically disqualify South Africa from continued participation in Agoa and would also oblige US representatives on the IMF and World Bank to veto any loans from those international financial institutions to South Africa.
In 2010, US support was vital to South Africa in securing a USD3.75 billion loan for its Medupi coal-fired power station.
Construction at Medupi power station
Dropping Section 20(d) is one of four demands which the US is making before it will allow South Africa to continue enjoying its very lucrative Agoa benefits, especially the export of cars.
The other three demands are for greater access for US chicken, beef and pork imports in South Africa which have been banned for up to 15 years, mainly on health grounds.
Earlier this year the US Congress passed legislation to extend Agoa, which is expiring this year, for another ten years. But it specifically made South Africa’s continued participation conditional on the country agreeing to make concessions on the four issues by a September 30 deadline.
Though this deadline has passed, an agreement between veterinarian experts from both sides at a meeting in Pretoria last month, seems to have pushed out the deadline until at least October 15.
That was the date they set each other for a final agreement on allowing a quota of 65,000 tonnes of US poultry into South Africa. The quota was agreed on in June but South Africa continued to cite outbreaks of avian flu in the US as a reason to block the imports.
Now Pretoria has agreed in principle to “regionalise” the poultry imports, by accepting US poultry from states where there is no avian flu.
Officials say South Africa has also backed off its earlier demand that its inspectors should be allowed to visit all US beef facilities to ensure none are contaminated with mad cow disease. It has agreed to be more selective.
The US says it has been declared free of the disease already by the World Animal Health Organisation OIE anyway.
And officials add that the two sides were also close to agreeing on a health certificate to allow some cuts of US pork into South Africa, after processing to avoid diseases risk.
US sources say that despite the narrowing of differences, bureaucratic procedures on the South African side are still causing long delays. They now hope the first US poultry imports will arrive before the end of the year.
Still, the meat threat to South Africa’s Agoa benefits seems to be fading. But if Zuma signs the security act into law as it now stands, all that will change.
Read related news articles
Key provisions of the US’s AGOA Improvement Act
The office of the US trade representative has been leading the 2024 US-Sub-Saharan Africa Trade & Economic Co-operation African Growth & Opportunity Act (Agoa) Forum in Washington this week. Convening under the theme “Beyond 2025: Reimagining Agoa for an Inclusive, Sustainable and Prosperous Tomorrow”, the forum brings together senior government officials from the US and Agoa-eligible countries, as well as representatives from...
26 July 2024
New government of national unity gives South Africa a honeymoon period for keeping its AGOA status, say analysts
New Trade and Industry Minister Parks Tau is fighting for South Africa's continued participation in AGOA at the AGOA Forum in Washington this week. The formation of the Government of National Unity (GNU) has secured South Africa a “honeymoon period” for retaining its privileged access to US markets under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa). This is the view of US politicians and South African trade analysts on the eve of the...
23 July 2024
Rosa Whitaker: 'America can't be first if we keep putting Africa last'
Given the press of events closer to home, Africa is hardly top of mind in Washington right now. That President Joe Biden's foreign policy, economic and trade A-team is meeting with its African counterparts here this week is unlikely to change that. In a more rational world, it would. The meeting is the 21st AGOA Forum, named after the African Growth and Opportunity Act, requires that the get-together be held annually. This year's session is...
23 July 2024
South Africa plans US mission to lobby against US review of ties
South Africa’s newly formed government will use an upcoming forum on US preferential trade access to push back against a Senate review of ties between the two countries. The House of Representatives last month passed a law requiring a full assessment off bilateral relations and submitted it to the Senate for approval. South African business lobby groups have warned the legislation threatens to curb trade with the world’s biggest economy...
15 July 2024
How access to US market changed the fortunes of two South African sisters
Two entrepreneurs take traditional African designs and sustainable materials and turn them into international success What started as a pastime desire to sell crafts at local markets, deeply rooted in the South African culture, has since blossomed to become an international business entity for two local women.It took the Mokone sisters, Morongwe "Mo" (37) and Michelle (34), three years only to turn around their home decor business into an...
01 July 2024
US-Africa trade deal turns 25 next year: AGOA's winners, losers and what should come next
The African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) is a landmark piece of trade legislation enacted by the United States in 2000. Its goal is to promote economic growth, development and poverty reduction in sub-Saharan Africa by providing qualifying countries with duty-free access to the US market for over 6,500 products. By eliminating import tariffs and quotas, Agoa aims to stimulate trade, attract foreign investment and foster economic...
06 May 2024
African trade coalition backs AGOA 16-year renewal bill to boost trade prospects
The African Coalition for Trade (ACT) has voiced its support for the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) Renewal and Improvement Act of 2024 and credits the bill with creating hundreds of thousands of direct jobs in Africa and the US. The AGOA Renewal and Improvement Act of 2024 which was introduced by Senators Chris Coons and James Risch would extend the bill for 16 years until 2041 and continue to boost Africa’s duty-free status as...
18 April 2024
US apparel and footwear industry supports 16 year AGOA renewal
The American Apparel & Footwear Association applauds Senator Chris Coons (D-DE) and Senator James Risch (R-ID) for introducing the AGOA Renewal and Improvement Act of 2024.Currently set to expire in September 2025, AGOA is a pivotal trade preference program that provides duty-free access to the U.S. market, fostering economic growth and opportunity between the U.S. and eligible African countries. This program is the cornerstone of...
11 April 2024
US senators introduce bill to renew Africa trade pact through 2041 [Download copy]
A bipartisan group of senators will introduce a bill to renew the United States' trade pact with sub-Saharan Africa ahead of its expiration next year, an aide to one of the senators said on Thursday. [ Download it here and download a summary here] The bill was introduced by Senators Chris Coons, a Democrat, and James Risch, the top Republican on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. A cross-party group of...
11 April 2024
US manufacturing subsidies for Africa could help revive AGOA
Experts at the Center for Global Development argue that the unconventional approach could bring billions in new trade opportunities and would fit with US “friend-shoring” efforts. The US should pay ‘negative tariffs’ in Africa – essentially targeted manufacturing subsidies – to help revive its faltering African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), according to a new report from the Washington-based Center for Global...
05 April 2024
South Africa walks a tightrope on US relations
South Africa has been conducting a high-wire act in its relations with the United States (US). It is maintaining friendships with Washington’s enemies like Russia, Iran and China while trying to avoid disrupting its economic relations with America. Tensions came closer than ever to breaking point this month as the US House of Representatives’ Committee on Foreign Affairs passed the US-South Africa Bilateral Relations...
28 March 2024