- African Growth and Opportunity Act
TRALAC - Trade Law Centre
You are here: Home/News/Article/America 'squeezes AGOA for more juice'

America 'squeezes AGOA for more juice'

America 'squeezes AGOA for more juice'
Published date:
Sunday, 16 August 2015
Dewald Van Rensburg

Ever more US interests are trying to use the new and improved African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) to leverage policy concessions out of South Africa, seemingly undeterred by a “breakthrough” deal on chicken imports in June.

An “out-of-cycle” review of South Africa’s Agoa eligibility kicked off in Washington last week with a public hearing last Friday and a second round of public submissions got published this last week.

The US pharmaceutical, information and communication technology (ICT) and private security industries have joined in the better-known US meat-exporters’ attack on key trade and economic policies.

In the cross hairs are South Africa’s still-incomplete reform of intellectual property rules, planned limits on foreign ownership in the security sector and the regulation of electronic waste disposal, as well as the latest changes to broad-based BEE scorecards.

In their submissions, key US meat exporter groups are dismissive of the chicken quota deal struck in Paris in June, as well as the claimed progress towards reallowing banned US pork and beef products to enter South Africa, which the department of trade and industry had held up as practically ensuring South Africa’s continued inclusion in Agoa.

The department this week replied to its US critics, defending its steps on US meat imports and the importance of South Africa’s transformation policies.

Civil society groups went on a more aggressive offensive against the attempt to make South Africa back down from the more generics-friendly intellectual property policy proposals made in 2013.

The Treatment Action Campaign, Doctors Without Borders, Section 27 and the Stop Stock Outs Project railed against the attempts to leverage Agoa against these intellectual property reforms, which are largely aimed at improving the availability of life-saving medicine to treat HIV, TB and other endemic diseases.

Pharmaceutical companies have anonymously channelled complaints to the Agoa review through submissions by the American Chamber of Commerce and the National Foreign Trade Council. The intellectual property policy will intentionally “weaken current standards that are important to investors and innovators”, they say.

That is certainly the point, but the nongovernmental organisations point out that the proposals fall well within what is allowed under South Africa’s commitments under the international Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights. It also echoes previous reforms in other major developing countries.

The American Chamber of Commerce chimed in this week, saying that South Africa’s new broad-based BEE rules are too onerous because of the far higher weight given to local procurement.

“For many manufacturers with complex global supply chains, this is an unrealistic requirement and one that cannot be met without significant additional investments,” said the chamber, apparently speaking mostly on behalf of ICT interests.

The intellectual property policy was also a threat to US ICT imports, it said.

These associations are taking a far softer public approach than the US meat lobbies because their members actually have investments inside South Africa.

Losing Agoa would have a “debilitating impact on South Africa and ... the ability of American companies to do business in South Africa”, said the chamber in its submission.

They don’t want South Africa kicked out of Agoa, but think these qualms can serve as “leverage for action/changes in terms of policy issues that the South African government is pursuing”.

In a submission to the Agoa hearing, the USA Poultry andamp; Egg Export Council and the National Chicken Council treat the chicken deal from June with scepticism, saying that “the ball is in South Africa’s court” and that they will “accept nothing less” than actual US chicken pieces making it into South Africa before lifting the threat of cutting Agoa benefits.

“It is not enough to have reached an agreement in principle in Paris, or to initiate various legal processes in South Africa,” reads its submission.

The chicken deal would allow 65 000 tons of US bone-in chicken pieces to enter South Africa every year – free of the punitive anti-dumping duties that have in effect blocked the product since 2000.

The details for this scheme are still being finalised, but the South African side of the talks claims it is the Americans who are dragging their feet by not timeously responding to the draft agreement that has been drawn up.

The US’s National Pork Producers’ Council is, however, making the most aggressive argument for punitive measures against South Africa. This is in retaliation for the phytosanitary restrictions that have practically banned many US pork imports for more than a decade.

It called for all Agoa benefits to be withdrawn to “draw the attention of high-level officials to the anti-trade policies being enforced by government agencies”.

Despite the department of trade and industry claiming significant progress in hashing out a deal on pork, the National Pork Producers’ Council claims that there has been “no meaningful progress”.

It then proposes that the US could stop short of totally excluding South Africa, but instead revoke market access for specific products, including oranges, wine and nuts – in essence everything South Africa exports under Agoa except for BMWs.


- See the South Africa Out-of-Cycle Review documents here


Read related news articles

South African ambassador upbeat over AGOA review

Despite a potentially contentious out-of-cycle review of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) being under way in Washington, SA’s ambassador to the US, Mninwa Mahlangu, remains upbeat that the country will continue to benefit from the trade concessions provided in the arrangement. Mr Mahlangu said SA had made progress in addressing the red flags raised by the US. "One of the issues (related) to poultry, (the) South African Poultry...

25 August 2015

SA trade official digs in on intellectual property draft

South Africa's Department of Trade and Industry is not going to pander to any side when it comes to its intellectual property policy, director-general Lionel October said on Thursday. The American Chamber of Commerce in SA (AmCham) has urged the US trade representative to use its review of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) to pressure SA’s government to change the draft policy in favour of US companies. AmCham represents 250...

14 August 2015

'Pharmaceutical industry attempting to undermine access to affordable medicines'

South Africa’s eligibility for ongoing inclusion in the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) is being used as a bargaining chip in pressure by the pharmaceutical industry to get the country to backtrack on intellectual property (IP) law reforms aimed at promoting access to more affordable medicines. The Fix the Patent Laws coalition - Treatment Action Campaign (TAC)‚ Doctors Without Borders (MSF)‚ SECTION27 and the Stop Stock Outs...

13 August 2015

US demand proof South Africa ready to lift meat bans

Sceptical US officials have demanded further evidence that Pretoria is ready to lift disease-related bans on US poultry, beef and pork. This was raised at Friday’s public hearing in the US on whether SA should continue to receive African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) trade privileges. To remain part of Agoa, SA would have to do more than "address US concerns", assistant Trade Representative Florie Liser told ambassador Mninwa Mahlangu...

11 August 2015

South Africa to put forward ‘strong argument’ in public bid to remain AGOA beneficiary

South Africa will be putting forward a strong argument in a public hearing in Washington DC on Friday that it should continue to be a beneficiary of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa). The public hearings are part of the out-of-cycle review of SA’s eligibility as a beneficiary, which was required in the new Agoa signed by US President Barack Obama last month. The review undertaken by the US Trade Representative has to take place...

04 August 2015

South Africa: Stalling on security providers bill could harm AGOA benefits

US ambassador to SA Patrick Gaspard has been given repeated assurances by the government that the controversial Private Security Industry Regulation Amendment Bill will be sent back to Parliament for amendments. The bill has been with the Presidency for about a year since its adoption by the National Assembly and National Council of Provinces, and presidential spokesman Harold Maloka said on Thursday it was "still under consideration". The...

19 June 2015

You are here: Home/News/Article/America 'squeezes AGOA for more juice'