- African Growth and Opportunity Act
TRALAC - Trade Law Centre
You are here: Home/News/Article/Top four moments from trade subcommittee hearing on reforms to the US GSP program

Top four moments from trade subcommittee hearing on reforms to the US GSP program

Top four moments from trade subcommittee hearing on reforms to the US GSP program
Published date:
Friday, 08 September 2023

On Wednesday, the Ways and Means Trade Subcommittee examined the Generalized System of Preferences (GSP) trade program and what possible reforms could help align the program better with America’s strategic trade goals. Witnesses emphasized the importance of the United States using trade policy to benefit American workers, farmers, and small businesses while combatting China’s unfair trade practices and coercive economic model.

GSP Can Be Reformed to Benefit American Workers and Producers and Help Move Supply Chains from China

America’s trade policy must be aligned with our strategic goals. Reforms in the program could help meet those goals, as one witness testified to Chairman Jason Smith (MO-08).

View on X (Twitter)


Chairman Smith (MO-08): “In addition to bringing more of our supply chains home, we want to strengthen trade relations in our backyard. Currently, U.S. content is not counted towards the rule-of-origin regional requirements under the GSP, like it is under the African Growth and Opportunity Act trade preferences and USMCA. Our trade policy should support American jobs at every opportunity. Should Congress consider changing the GSP rule-of-origin to allow GSP countries to purchase U.S. components to help meet the rule-of-origin, perhaps coupled with an increase in the 35 percent rule-of-origin threshold?”

rep smith hearings1200

Mr. Houseman, United Steelworkers: The short answer – yes…So there’s an opportunity here. If we raise the standard, we’re asking our trading partners to do a little bit more for those producers in those countries. And then at the same time, American producers could benefit as well. And I think that’s a key element that really is a value to add to the GSP program.”

American Producers Must Not Be Undermined By Trade Preference Programs

In his questions, Trade Subcommittee Chairman Adrian Smith (NE-03) pointed out the importance of careful scrutiny to make sure GSP rules allow removal of any products from the program that might undermine American workers and producers.

Rep. Smith: “Now there’s been the accusation that the GSP has undermined domestic production. Mr. Gresser, can you elaborate on how GSP can be fashioned, or how it already is, in terms of import-sensitive products?”

Mr. Gresser, former administrator for GSP: “It has, as an integral and important part of the program, a petitioning process where interested parties can ask USTR to remove a product from the eligible list. While I was working on the program, we had such a petition from USA rice, which resulted in the removal of most rice products. We had such a petition from the Michigan cherry board, which resulted in the removal of cherry juice. This is an important part of the program. It works if there are particular products that are becoming sensitive. Everyone has a right to file such a petition.”

America Must Respond to China’s Exploitation of American Businesses

Foreign countries increasingly seek to exploit American innovation and leadership through unfair regulations related to digital trade and taxation. Rep. Darin LaHood (IL-16) asked about the importance of American leadership on digital trade to prevent the further spread of China’s harmful model of restrictive digital trade rules that harm American innovators and workers while benefiting Chinese companies.

View on X (Twitter)


Rep. LaHood: “If we do not put forward stronger digital trade provisions, talk about the competitive advantage we continue to cede to China in this space.”

Mr. Cory, trade expert: “Yep, it’s most definitely happening. Indonesia is a great example whereby Chinese cloud firms have gone into Indonesia and explicitly told the Indonesian officials that we are completely fine with data localization and other restrictions because it’s what they’re used to operating in China. They’re doing that explicitly to disadvantage U.S. tech firms because they recognize that U.S. firms obviously operate differently. And so there is this global competition in and around these regulations. And if the U.S. firms can’t rely on the U.S. government to help them push back on these types of restrictions, U.S. firms are going to lose out, and that will continue to happen in more and more countries, as they also consider China-like data localization restrictions.”

“Very Simple”: Tougher Enforcement Key to Helping Farmers Export More

Greater access to a foreign market would give American farmers more customers and provide foreign countries with a safe, affordable food supply. In response to Rep. Greg Steube (FL-17), a pork producer shared how farmers would be greatly helped by tough enforcement of program rules.

Rep. Steube:“How can the GSP be augmented to maintain American dominance in ag exports to beneficiary countries?”

View on X (Twitter)


Mr. Spronk, pork producer: “Very simple. Stronger enforcement mechanisms and more quickly responding, so that it doesn’t take so long to be able to do that enforcement. Those two things are very important to us.”

Background: Before expiring in 2020, the Generalized System of Preferences was America’s largest trade preference program. The program was first authorized in 1974. Historically, the program aims to promote economic development and raise standards in developing countries while providing cost savings to American businesses and consumers on products that are not available from U.S. suppliers. Exports from 119 beneficiary developing countries that meet the program rules receive duty-free access to the U.S. market for a select list of exports.

  Watch a recording of the hearings below

Read related news articles

AGOA Coalition warns Congress: Duty-free imports sought by US apparel makers would vitiate Africa trade

AGOA Action Coalition letter to Congress on GSP modernization provisions The following letter was sent by the Agoa Action Coalition to the chairman of the U.S. House Ways and Means Subcommittee on Trade Earl Blumenauer (Democrat-Oregon), as well as the chairman of the full committee, Richard Neal (Democrat-Massachusetts) and ranking Committee member Kevin Brady (Republican-Texas), and ranking Trade Subcommittee member Vern Buchanan...

03 September 2020

Federal Register - South Africa GSP Review dates

The Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) is announcing a hearing for the GSP country practice reviews of Azerbaijan, Ecuador, Georgia, Indonesia, Kazakhstan, Thailand, South Africa, and Uzbekistan, and the country designation review of Laos. These reviews will focus on whether: (1) Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, and Uzbekistan are meeting the GSP eligibility criterion requiring that a GSP beneficiary country afford...

19 November 2019

SA business organisation asks president to delay enactment of two Bills to ensure continued US trade benefits

Business organisation Sakeliga has requested President Cyril Ramaphosa to delay the enactment of two Bills of Parliament, which it says could potentially jeopardise 40% of South Africa’s exports to the US. The relevant Bills are the Copyright Amendment Bill (B13B-2017) and the Performer’s Protection Bill (B24B-2016). Sakeliga’s open letter on Monday follows an announcement made last week by the Office of the US Trade...

28 October 2019

R35 billion in South African exports to the USA are at stake in a 'review' just triggered by SA's copyright reform efforts

South African exports to the United States worth some R35 billion last year will be at stake when the Office of the United States Trade Representative launches a review of SA's eligibility for duty-free imports under the US system known as the Generalized System of Preferences, or GSP. The US federal government announced plans for the review on Friday. The exports threatened include – but go beyond – exports to...

27 October 2019

US announces a review of South Africa's place in its biggest preferential trade scheme (GSP)

The United States plans to review South Africa's eligibility to participate in its Generalized System of Preferences (GSP), the largest and oldest American scheme to allow duty-free imports from less developed countries. The South African review is "based on IP [intellectual property] protection and enforcement concerns", the Office of the United States Trade Representative said in an announcement on Friday. [See...

26 October 2019

Presidential Proclamation to take certain actions under the AGOA and for other purposes

In Proclamation 9223 of December 23, 2014, President Obama determined that the Republic of The Gambia (“The Gambia”) was not making continual progress in meeting the requirements described in section 506A(a)(1) of the Trade Act of 1974, as amended (the “Trade Act”) (19 U.S.C. 2466a(a)), as added by section 111(a) of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (the “AGOA”). Thus, pursuant to section 506A(a)(3) of the Trade Act (19 U.S.C....

23 December 2017

USTR announces new enforcement priorities for GSP

US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer today announced a new effort to ensure beneficiary countries are meeting the eligibility criteria of the Generalized System of Preferences (GSP) trade preference program.  This new effort includes a heightened focus on concluding outstanding GSP cases and a new interagency process to assess beneficiary country eligibility. This interagency process complements the current petition receipt and...

24 October 2017

GSP changes leave preferences intact for AGOA beneficiaries

"Deep disappointment" has been expressed over the exclusion of travel goods produced in the Philippines, Thailand, Pakistan, Indonesia, and Sri Lanka from duty-free status under the US Generalized System of Preferences (GSP) program, following the US Administration's recent annual review. Under the GSP program, approximately 5,000 products from 122 beneficiary developing countries and territories, including 43 least developed countries, are...

08 July 2016

You are here: Home/News/Article/Top four moments from trade subcommittee hearing on reforms to the US GSP program