- African Growth and Opportunity Act
TRALAC - Trade Law Centre
You are here: Home/News/Article/Opinon: 'Is it worth antagonising the US with Russia and China relations?

Opinon: 'Is it worth antagonising the US with Russia and China relations?

Opinon: 'Is it worth antagonising the US with Russia and China relations?
Published date:
Sunday, 26 February 2023

In the middle of an energy crisis and greylisting, SA could do without antagonising one of its biggest trade and investment partners.

When SA welcomed the Russian warship Admiral Gorshkov — with the Kremlin’s pro-war symbol, the letter “Z”, on prominent display — it sparked a new diplomatic crisis with the US that could have profound economic consequences.   

This past week the US Congress introduced a resolution to reconsider its relationship with SA. House Resolution 145 opposes SA’s hosting of military exercises with Russia and China and calls on the Biden administration to “conduct a thorough review of the US-SA relationship”.

You have to wonder: is it really worth it? And if so, for whom, and for what? Ahead of the first democratic elections in 1994 Nelson Mandela authored an article for Foreign Affairs outlining the ANC’s foreign policy stance and how it wanted to engage on the international stage: “Our belief [is] that human rights should be the core concern of international relations.”

This was a commitment to principled foreign policy and a rejection of the undiluted pursuit of self-interest. Russia’s behaviour has been the antithesis of this human rights commitment. So does a closer relationship with Russia advance SA’s economic interest? Does Russia offer SA something that provides reprieve amid the hardships, bearing in mind that the country’s growth rates that exceed 3% between 2010 and 2020 and a lack of investment has driven an unemployment rate in excess of 30% throughout that period?

And it’s not national interest either. Russia contributes less than 0.5% of SA’s international trade. Its total investment in SA remains a measly $1.5bn. SA’s decision to strengthen its alliance with one pariah state — Russia — and another that’s likely to become one due to its support to Russia and impending efforts to annex Taiwan (China), is likely to be of consequence for two things SA needs most: trade and investment.

Whether passed or not, House resolution 145 lays the foundation for economic levers the US can use in future.

In 2000 US president Bill Clinton signed the African Growth & Opportunity Act (Agoa), which gave African countries a competitive edge by providing unilateral duty-free exports for 6,500 products from Africa to the US.

Throughout the life of Agoa it has been leveraged as a tool to support human rights. In recent years Cameroon, Guinea, Mali, Ethiopia and Burkina Faso have experienced a loss of benefits on the back of shortcomings. Some suspensions had larger economic consequences than others: Guinea and Mali exported little to the US — less than 1% of total exports — so the fallout was limited. Ethiopia, on the other hand, took a far larger hit as the US was the second-biggest importer of Ethiopian goods. The loss of Agoa benefits triggered large-scale divestment within weeks.

Under the circumstances American senators are, with good reason, asking why SA should have preferential trade terms with the US when it’s de facto supporting a wartime enemy and perpetrator of human rights atrocities.

SA would, in absolute terms, be the biggest loser on the continent if it lost its Agoa benefits. SA is the largest African exporter and has the most diversified export range, sending goods from 11 sectors to the US. Exports are primarily concentrated in minerals and metals, transportation equipment, chemicals, agriculture and an array of manufactured goods.

Five years ago it would have been a fair question to ask whether the US might turn a blind eye given its need for commodities produced by SA, including manganese, platinum and chromium. But if we’ve learnt anything from Russia’s natural gas saga it is that the US is willing to take a hardline human rights stance, even if it’s an economic inconvenience.

Beyond Agoa, bringing the trade partnership into peril could have dire economic consequences. SA Revenue Service datashows that in December the US was the biggest importer of SA goods.

The trade implications may be mirrored by the EU given that it and the US have largely moved in policy sync as it relates to Ukraine. SA is also a beneficiary of the Southern African Development Community-EU Economic Partnership Agreement, another preferential trade programme.

At a time when SA is aiming to grow its exports and explicitly seeking out new trade partners to line up off-takers for ramped-up production, upsetting existing trade partners is ill advised. 

The US is the biggest source of foreign direct investment in SA — valued at $7.6bn. Roughly 600 American employment-facilitating businesses operate in SA.

The arrival of the Admiral Gorshkov signalled that SA was willing to face potential divestment and future deterrence to new investment. Would you bring long-term investment into a country that’s been severely sanctioned by most major economies and suspended by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF)?

It was short-sighted, at best, for a country that’s gone to great lengths to attract foreign direct investment and prided itself in being an export-led economy. It was also short-sighted, considering that SA knew FATF greylisting was imminent. Yet still, it took a well-planned economic gamble.

Within a week of the Admiral Gorshkov arriving SA was formally and independently identified as a threat to the international financial system by the FATF, bringing inevitable consequences on trade and transactions with other countries. It became the second Group of 20 nation to be greylisted. This means future investment challenges will extend to the rest of the world.

By 2021 there had been enough research to show that greylisting had a big impact on a country’s capital flows — an average of -7.6% of GDP, though this varied by flow. Additionally, on average foreign direct investment inflows declined by 3%, portfolio inflows 2.9% and investment inflows 3.6%. SA’s recent foreign policy behaviour and energy crisis is likely to amplify the impact.

It’s a credible argument that the historical support to the liberation struggle during the apartheid era by the Soviet Union and China has played a hand in how things have played out. But it’s certainly worth rethinking SA’s approach given the economic consequences that are hanging over our heads at a time when the country has little economic resilience left.

SA needs to start thinking long term. A future of economic growth and prosperity cannot come when intertwined with the status of global pariah. History won’t look favourably on this one.

Dr Baskaran (@gracebaskaran), a development economist, is a bye-fellow in economics at the University of Cambridge

Read related news articles

Renewed commitment: South Africa to host AGOA summit amid calls for extension

South Africa is set to host the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) Summit later this year, despite recent diplomatic tensions between the country and the United States (US). In June this year, US legislators called for the relocation of the summit due to controversy surrounding alleged arms shipments to Russia by South Africa. Cleared of any wrongdoing by an internal judicial panel, the US has reaffirmed its commitment to shared growth...

21 September 2023

South Africa confirmed as AGOA host country for 2023

United States Trade Representative Katherine Tai and South African Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition Ebrahim Patel today announced that the Government of South Africa will host the 20th US-sub-Saharan Africa Trade and Economic Cooperation Forum (AGOA Forum) in Johannesburg, from November 2-4, 2023. The Forum will bring together the governments of the United States and AGOA-eligible countries, as well as representatives from key...

20 September 2023

South Africa well positioned as Africa's industrial centre: President Ramaphosa

President Cyril Ramaphosa has told American business representatives that Africa is ready for new investment and strong partnerships. The President was delivering remarks at the US - South Africa Trade and Investment Business Roundtable Dialogue in New York on Monday.  “Africa is ready for new investment and strong partnerships. South Africa is well positioned as the continent’s industrial centre, with deep capital markets, the rule...

19 September 2023

US Chamber of Commerce hosts South African president Ramaphosa to deepen bilateral trade, investment ties

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce is organizing a record number of meetings and events on the sidelines of the 78th session of the UN General Assembly (UNGA) to help foster public-private collaboration and underscore the indispensable role of the private sector in realizing the UN’s global targets. As part of this effort, the U.S. Chamber’s U.S.-Africa Business Center (USAfBC) today hosted the U.S.-South Africa Trade and Investment Executive...

18 September 2023

South Africa: Trade high on Ramaphosa’s US agenda

In an effort to extend South Africa’s preferential trade agreement with the US, trade, industry & competition minister Ebrahim Patel is holding high-level meetings with US legislators ahead of the UN General Assembly this week.  President Cyril Ramaphosa is understood to have attended some of the meetings, including with senator Gregory Meeks, the foreign affairs committee chair who called on the US to strip SA of the right to...

17 September 2023

South Africa and the US aim to put AGOA storm behind them

The coming AGOA forum, intended to map the way forward for US-SA trade relations, presents an opportunity for SA and the US to move on from the diplomatic storm stemming from perceptions that Pretoria sides with Russia in its war on Ukraine, says a top Washington official.  SA-US tension escalated in May after US ambassador to Pretoria Reuben Brigety accused SA of providing arms to Russia in December 2022. The presidency released a...

14 September 2023

Loss of ‘bedrock’ AGOA will hurt South African motor industry, warns new report

Loss of access to US trade benefits through the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) would hurt not only the SA motor industry but also many more across Africa that depend on it for their future growth, says a new report.  Attempts to create a pan-African motor industry and quintuple the size of the continent’s new-vehicle market could be undermined if the SA industry, the strategy’s main driver, is weakened, the report by motor...

02 September 2023

A warming between South Africa and the US on the eve of BRICS summit

On the eve of the 15th BRICS summit, both SA and US diplomatic sources say they believe that relations between the two countries have improved, with the US adding that there has been more engagement in the past six months than in the past decade. The BRICS summit, which starts in Sandton on Wednesday afternoon, will highlight SA's relationship with two of the US's global opponents: Russia, with which it is indirectly at war, and China, with...

22 August 2023

South Africa: $1bn citrus industry highlights importance of inclusion in AGOA

On Friday, the Standing Committee on Finance, Economic Opportunities and Tourism met with key stakeholders in the citrus industry at Market Demand Fruits, Stellenbosch. The meeting focussed on the detrimental impact on citrus exports to the United States should South Africa not be included in the reauthorisation of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). These stakeholders included representatives from Summer Citrus South Africa,...

20 August 2023

Rhetoric aside, the US needs South Africa inside the AGOA tent, not outside

The South African government sent a senior ministerial delegation to the US to make its case for keeping South Africa as a beneficiary of its trade preferences under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). Most commentators focus on the benefits of Agoa to South Africa, but there are good reasons that it is very much in America’s interests to keep South Africa as a trading partner and within its sphere of influence through Agoa...

27 July 2023

South Africa asks US for early AGOA extension

South Africa has asked the US to consider an early extension to the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa), saying this would provide certainty for investors and encourage them to commit additional investment on the continent. Trade, industry & competition minister Ebrahim Patel said the expeditious renewal trade agreement, which gives SA and other sub-Saharan African countries preferential access to US markets, would be beneficial not...

25 July 2023

You are here: Home/News/Article/Opinon: 'Is it worth antagonising the US with Russia and China relations?