- African Growth and Opportunity Act
TRALAC - Trade Law Centre
You are here: Home/News/Article/'AGOA shows US has successfully courted Africa' - Columnist

'AGOA shows US has successfully courted Africa' - Columnist

'AGOA shows US has successfully courted Africa' - Columnist
Published date:
Thursday, 26 January 2023

US treasury secretary Janet Yellen is in town this week. While news headlines have focused on the overlapping visits to the continent of Yellen, Russia’s Sergey Lavrov and China’s Qin Gang, Yellen’s comparative advantage is marked.

She’s a pre-eminent economist — the first to have led the Federal Reserve, the White House council of economic advisers and the treasury — and she’s here to leverage that experience to build US-Africa relations.

Fellow columnist John Dludlu recently suggested Washington’s overtures to Africa are likely to fail, in part because the US has lost its race to court Africa through trade. (“Too little, too late for the US to counter China in Africa”, January 18). I disagree.

In 2000, then US president Bill Clinton signed the African Growth & Opportunities Act (Agoa), which gave Sub-Saharan African countries a competitive edge by unilaterally allowing them duty-free exports for 6,500 products to the US. In 2021 Africa exported $4.8bn in non-oil goods to the US through Agoa — that's more than the GDPs of 13 African countries.

When discussing US-Africa trade there are three evidence-backed points to be made: without Agoa, some smaller Sub-Saharan African countries would never have developed a private sector; when countries have had their Agoa benefits suspended it’s led to an exodus of investment, indicating that the competitive edge Agoa offers is vital to investors; and Agoa has become an economic diplomacy tool the US has leveraged to reduce human rights abuse. Whether it’s the best tool for the purpose is up for discussion.

Agoa has clearly been the driving factor behind the development of the private sector in some Sub-Saharan African countries. In Lesotho, the manufacturing industry grew from a handful of factories in the 1990s to become the largest private sector employer after Agoa was instated, providing employment for 40,000 people and exporting mainly American brands such as Old Navy, Walmart and Levi’s to the value of about $250m.

China has never provided any incentives to attract investment to Lesotho. On the contrary, China’s manufacturing firms came to Lesotho so they could benefit from Agoa and tap the US market. When Agoa benefits are withdrawn evidence from multiple countries shows investment leaves — including Chinese firms.

In 2011 Eswatini exported $73m in textiles and apparel to the US through Agoa. In 2015 the US suspended Eswatini’s Agoa benefits due to its poor labour and human rights record. Many of the 30 (largely Chinese-owned) textile and apparel factories immediately relocated.

China didn’t step into the breach and provide similar incentives to retain investment. In 2017, after Eswatini resolved its ills, Agoa was reinstated and a national Agoa utilisation strategy was developed to increase exports from Eswatini to the US and boost US investment.

We’re seeing a similar script play out in Ethiopia. In 2016 I visited the bustling industrial park in Hawassa, which hosted factories producing for H&M and PVH, whose brands include Tommy Hilfiger and Calvin Klein. In 2021, two weeks after President Joe Biden announced Ethiopia’s suspension from Agoa’s benefits for gross human rights violations, PVH announced that it would close its factories. It’s hard to prove causation, but the correlation is strong.

Agoa offers a unique insight into the divergent approach the US and China have taken on the African continent. I want to preface this carefully — I believe targeted sanctions are generally preferable to economy-wide ones, because the latter can put thousands out of work.

The US decided to suspend Ethiopia’s Agoa benefits as it worked on targeted sanctions. It was a significant blow. It would have been easier for the US to do nothing — after all, the Ethiopian government has been a strategic ally in the Horn of Africa, where radicalisation and instability are rife.

Shortly after the AU brokered a ceasefire, Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed requested that Agoa benefits be reinstated. He clearly realised its value.

I am uncomfortable that China didn’t lift an economic finger to incentivise Ethiopia to end a war that’s killed upwards of 500,000 people. It simply watched from the sidelines. Silence is complicity.

The argument that US hasn’t “courted” Africa through trade is unfounded. Africa. Agoa has been a backbone for building a competitive private sector, generating jobs (350,000 direct jobs and over a million indirect jobs), and increasing revenue. It’s courted it, within the parameters of decency, rather than at the expense of it.

In next week’s column I will critically assess the question of whether African countries have really been drawn to the “warm embrace” of China. 

Dr Baskaran (@gracebaskaran), a development economist, is a bye-fellow in economics at the University of Cambridge.


Read related news articles

Opinion: 'Continuing challenges for African trade'

The beneficial effects of trade on any economy are well known, and an upscaled trading ability for SA would go a long way to improving its economic position. Benefits would be particularly extensive if they were those flowing from innovative downstream facets of the economy which expanded value-add supply chains.  Naturally enough, all this needs a growth-conducive context dependent on a variety of factors. Concrete steps must be...

28 November 2023

Protection likely for African countries that outgrow AGOA

The improved agreement of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), due to expire in 2025, is likely to have fewer requirements for graduation from the programme to avoid beneficiaries losing out on the lucrative commercial ties with the US, says a top Washington diplomat. The legislation, which was enacted in 2000 and allows Sub-Saharan African countries preferential access to US markets, requires that beneficiaries be graduated out of...

06 November 2023

Recalibrating US economic engagement with Africa

Nearly 23 years since the United States established the African Growth and Opportunity Act, or AGOA, the continent it was created for no longer exists. In the last two decades, there have been three major shifts that have worked together to cultivate a new Africa—an Africa that requires a different approach to trade and economic investment. First, there are China’s development initiatives, which have resulted in roads, rails, bridges, and...

18 April 2023

Taking stock of America’s flagship trade programme for Africa

Pankaj Bedi strides through his factory on the edge of Nairobi, past clattering sewing machines, bustling workers and boxes of jeans. None of this would be here, he says, were it not for the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). The landmark trade policy was introduced by Bill Clinton in 2000, granting duty-free access for more than 6,000 products from sub-Saharan Africa. Two years later, Mr Bedi opened United Aryan, his clothing...

08 February 2023

US and Kenya to hold first round under their Strategic Trade and Investment Partnership (STIP)

The United States and Kenya will hold an in-person round of conceptual discussions under their Strategic Trade and Investment Partnership (STIP) in Washington, DC, from February 6-10, 2023.   The United States delegation will be led by Assistant United States Trade Representative Connie Hamilton, and will include representatives from several other government agencies. United States Trade Representative Katherine Tai and then-Kenyan...

04 February 2023

US treasury secretary Janet Yellen touts deeper ties with South Africa to help boost trade

The US is seeking to deepen its economic integration with South Africa in pursuit of policies to diversify global supply chains, US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said. Closer ties with nations that share the US’s economic values will help promote so-called friendshoring, in which allies cooperate on manufacturing and sourcing raw materials, Yellen said at a meeting with South African Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana on...

25 January 2023

US and AfCFTA members sign MOU on trade cooperation

On December 14, 2022, the United States and African Continental Free Trade Area Secretariat (AfCFTA) signed a Memorandum of Understanding on Cooperation for Trade and Investment between the United States and the African Continental Free Trade Area (MOU) see document alongside.  The MOU  was signed by U.S. Trade Representative (USTR) Katherine Tai and AfCFTA Secretary General Wamkele Mene during the 2022 U.S.-Africa...

15 December 2022

Op-Ed | Africa-US: Commercial ties will shape the partnership in the 21st century

In early August, with its release of its strategy toward sub-Saharan Africa, the Biden-Harris administration laid out a bold vision for a 21st-century US-Africa partnership. The strategy and the upcoming Africa Leaders Summit, which President Biden and his deputy Harris will host in December, comes at the right time. Africa’s economic transformation — spurred by its young and rapidly urbanising populations, digitalisation initiatives,...

01 December 2022

Biden’s Africa strategy seeks to revitalize ties with the continent

President Biden is delivering on his commitment to make Africa a priority for the United States. Most notable is his administration’s sharp uptick in U.S. diplomacy toward the region. With visits to Kenya, Nigeria, and Senegal last November, Morocco and Algeria in March, and South Africa, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Rwanda this month, Secretary of State Antony Blinken has visited the continent three times in just 10...

25 August 2022

US revamps Africa strategy as it sounds alarm on China, Russia

The US unveiled a new strategy to forge closer relations with Sub-Saharan Africa, while contending that China and Russia were motivated by narrow self-interests in their attempts to strengthen ties with the region. With one of the world’s fastest-growing populations, largest free-trade areas by geographical area and most diverse set of ecosystems, Africa has a critical role to play in addressing the world’s defining challenges, the White...

10 August 2022

You are here: Home/News/Article/'AGOA shows US has successfully courted Africa' - Columnist