Opinion: A bipartisan legacy of Africa trade worth remembering

Opinion: A bipartisan legacy of Africa trade worth remembering
Monday, 18 May 2020 ~ Tom Sheehy

In a White House ceremony twenty years ago this week, former U.S. President Bill Clinton signed into law the African Growth and Opportunity Act.

While AGOA hasn’t met all of its lofty goals, this trade legislation has helped lift many Africans out of poverty.  

Today, with the global economy bordering on coronavirus-sparked turmoil and African economies bracing for great damage, it’s worth considering AGOA’s past and future, and celebrating the bipartisan collaboration that made this landmark initiative possible.      

A small, bipartisan group in the House of Representatives devised and drove AGOA. They were liberals and conservatives, including Ed Royce, Jim McDermott, Bill Archer, Charley Rangel, Phil Crane, and Don Payne, who forged a comradery over the several years it took to succeed. 

None had much of an electoral incentive to do the laborious and challenging work of passing meaningful legislation. If anything, they faced labor union opposition or constituent hostility about why they were working on Africa.

These lawmakers instead were motivated by a humanitarian concern and a sense that Africa would never develop if it remained so greatly marginalized from world trade, that the continent needed trade at least as much as aid, and that many African countries had potential to become important trading partners with the United States. They also felt that the world’s wealthiest economy could afford to give a leg up to the world’s poorest continent.

AGOA is a preferential trade program. It grants 6,400 African products duty-free access to the U.S. market, only expecting that the producing country honors basic criteria, including rule of law and governance standards. The AGOA approach reflected the fact that African agricultural-based economies were simply not ready to enter into negotiated free-trade agreements with the most advanced economy in the world. 

AGOA has managed to economically uplift tens of thousands of Africans, if not more, providing many with their first formal sector job. Several U.S. retailers have used AGOA to source apparel from Ethiopia, Tanzania, Madagascar, and elsewhere. South Africa exports BMW autos to the U.S. under AGOA, showing that the continent does have world-class manufacturing ability. 

Yet Africa remains a very small U.S. partner, with two-way trade levels only starting to stabilize at around a modest $40 billion after falling precipitously with the 2007-08 global financial crisis. And Africa’s role in world trade has remained stagnant, at around only 2%. 

Looking back, AGOA supporters underestimated the challenges of boosting international trade and investment on the continent. Poor infrastructure, high shipping costs, and lax rule of law continue to stifle commerce. While some African countries have benefited substantially from AGOA, many others have not. Yet their faith in Africa’s potential has been borne out by impressive economic growth in some countries, including Ethiopia, while a young generation of technology-savvy African entrepreneurs is driving the continent forward.

AGOA also sparked a raft of initiatives through successive administrations that support market reform and U.S. commercial interests in Africa. The Millennium Challenge Corporation prioritizes U.S. assistance for countries strengthening the rule of law and creating supportive commercial climates. 

The Trump administration has followed suit with “Prosper Africa” to bolster U.S. commercial activity on the continent. Most encouraging, African countries have launched an Africa Continental Free Trade Area to lower their own trade barriers.         

So what’s next? The Trump administration would like to move beyond AGOA.  

Earlier this year, it initiated free trade negotiations with Kenya, in which it will press U.S. interests on tariff rates, intellectual property, and food safety standards. Administration officials note that AGOA includes language aspiring to free-trade agreements and that preferential trade programs are not meant to be permanent. Winning trade deal concessions from Kenya and others is certainly harder when you already grant generous market access through AGOA.

Yet we should proceed with caution. Entering one or even several free trade agreements with African states would not equal the continent-wide market access of AGOA. Picking a few trade deal winners would stress commercial and political relations with dozens of Africa countries at a time when China and many other countries are courting them. Meanwhile, the uncertainty about whether Congress will extend AGOA beyond its 2025 expiration reportedly deters some investors from betting on Africa.

The coronavirus pandemic raises the stakes. The World Bank projects that African economies will shrink by 5% this year. Angola and Nigeria are suffering a double whammy, as world energy markets collapse. Emergent African industries will lose if global supply lines shorten. Tourism has collapsed.  

All this will have devastating human consequences. Maybe AGOA’s market-based development approach is more relevant than ever, and the program should be expanded, adding certain omitted agricultural items, rather than jettisoned?      

Africa needs more friends in Congress like it had two decades ago. Perhaps AGOA has come up short in some ways, but it has done much good and no harm. 

And while it has improved the lives of Africans, advanced U.S. interests on the continent, not unimportantly, it showed that a diverse array of U.S. legislators could work successfully for a good cause and little credit. That experience alone is worth reflecting upon during our troubled times.    

  • Tom Sheehy is the principal of Quinella Global, a Washington, D.C.-based public policy consulting company. From 1997-2018, he served on the staff of the Foreign Affairs Committee in the U.S. House of Representatives, the last six years as its staff director.


View related news articles

Blog: 'It’s Time for AGOA 2.0'

The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) is set to expire in 2025. That may be the distant future for some but given the time required to pass trade legislation in the U.S. Congress, it’s the functional equivalent of tomorrow’s mid-day meal. Preparation for the post-AGOA trade relationship between the U.S. and Africa needs to begin now. AGOA has had important successes but improvements need to be made to the program. The...

25 September 2019

Africa wants one trade deal with the US, the US wants many

The US and Africa have different views on their future trade relationship when a preferential access deal expires in 2025. US Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs Tibor Nagy said in an interview Sunday his country favours bilateral trade agreements with African nations. A day later, African Union Trade and Industry Commissioner Albert Muchanga said the African Union (AU) favours a free-trade agreement with the...

06 August 2019

US House Black Caucus to advocate extension of AGOA

The Majority Chief Whip of the United States House of Representatives, Mr James Clyburn, has said the Black Caucus in the US Legislature will advocate the extension of the African Growth and Opportunities Act (AGOA) to 25 years when the current agreement expires in 2025. He said it was the view of the caucus that America’s future with Ghana and other African countries should centre on trade and not aid. “We consider aid to be important...

02 August 2019

AGOA - good for Africa, warts and all?

The African Trade and Opportunities Act (AGOA), established by the United States government on May 18, 2000, has been described as the cornerstone of the U.S. economic engagement with sub-Saharan Africa, where it has invested more than U.S.$7 billion towards trade capacity initiatives. Some say AGOA was the U.S. government's answer to China's growing presence on the African continent. But what is the U.S. strategy as AGOA nears its end,...

24 July 2019

Republican Ed Royce’s respectful interest in Africa will be missed

Over the past quarter century, few members of the US Congress have taken a more serious, supportive or politically brave interest in Africa than Republican Ed Royce, now chairman of the house foreign affairs committee and for many years previously its Africa subcommittee. None would be less likely than this frequent visitor to use barnyard epithets to describe the continent or its people. Earlier in January, the Orange County, California,...

19 January 2018

House of Reps passes AGOA and MCA Modernization Act

Today, Rep. Karen Bass (D-Calif.), Ranking Member of the House Africa Subcommittee, applauded the passage of the African Growth & Opportunity Act (AGOA) and Millennium Challenge Act (MCA) Modernization Act, which passed by a unanimous voice vote on the House (of Representatives) Floor. The bill, introduced by House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Ed Royce (R-Calif.), will make AGOA more effective by directing the President to establish...

17 January 2018

What is the AGOA and MCA Modernization Act?

The African Growth and Opportunity Act, or AGOA, was passed into law by the 200th Congress on May 18, 2000. The bill was renewed up to the year 2025 in 2015, during the Obama administration. The primary purpose of the AGOA legislation is to establish a new trade and investment policy for sub-Saharan Africa, along with expanding trade benefits to the Caribbean Basin. The bill greatly improves the access that sub-Saharan...

27 November 2017

Reps Brady & Reichert express strong support for AGOA as US co-hosts forum in Togo

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Today, House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Kevin Brady (R-TX) and Trade Subcommittee Chairman Dave Reichert (R-WA) issued the following statements as the United States and Togo co-host the 2017 African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) Forum this week to further strengthen important economic ties between the United States and Africa. Reinforcing his support for AGOA, Chairman Brady said: “The bipartisan 10-year...

08 August 2017

Royce, Engel, Smith, Bass work to strengthen US-Africa trade

House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Ed Royce (R-CA), joined by Ranking Member Eliot Engel (D-NY) and Reps. Chris Smith (R-NJ) and Karen Bass (D-CA), introduced today the AGOA and MCA Modernization Act (H.R. 3445).  > Download a copy of the Bill as well as a separate summary at the links alongside.  The bipartisan legislation strengthens both the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) and the Millennium Challenge Act...

27 July 2017

SA government urged to engage with US administration to preserve AGOA

The ruling African National Congress (ANC) on Sunday urged the South African government to engage with the new US administration to preserve the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). In its Policy Discussion Document which underscores the importance of bridging the gap between the developed North and the developing South, the ANC said the new administration in the US has not yet pronounced on its Africa policy, and to this end "we will...

11 June 2017