- African Growth and Opportunity Act
TRALAC - Trade Law Centre
You are here: Home/News/Article/Potential US-Kenya trade pact meets with muted response

Potential US-Kenya trade pact meets with muted response

Potential US-Kenya trade pact meets with muted response
Published date:
Thursday, 20 February 2020

Following a meeting between US President Donald Trump and his Kenyan counterpart Uhuru Kenyatta earlier this month, Washington has officially initiated trade agreement negotiations with the East African country.

While United States Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer has hailed the “enormous potential” for the two sides to deepen their economic and commercial ties, the extent to which any eventual deal would boost trade is under question.

Kenya is far from the US’s biggest export market in Africa – South Africa holds that title. Indeed, it is currently the US’s 98th largest goods trading partner overall, with just US$1bn in annual two-way trade.

US imports from Kenya include apparel, tree nuts and coffee, many of which fall under the duty-free African Growth Opportunity Act (Agoa), which ends in 2025. Kenya’s imports are dominated by oil, chemicals, machinery and transport equipment – mostly from China, from which it buys around US$3.8bn of goods each year.

For Scott Eisner, president of the US-Africa business centre at the US Chamber of Commerce, a potential trade deal could open new doors for US exporters. “We have seen a long track record with the Kenyans, whether it be in the agriculture space or processing for companies in the horticultural processing space,” he says. “Beyond that, we have seen diversification on a number of fronts, whether you look at the digital economy and the Silicon Savannah, or at investments in medical devices and other industries involved in the health and wellness of the Kenyan population.”

He adds that the Kenyan market offers an “interesting solution” for US companies as the cost of doing business in Asia increases, particularly for the textile and garment industry.

Kenya’s growing middle class is also attractive to investors selling consumer goods. Research firm Oxford Economics ranks the country among the fastest-growing consumer markets on the continent, with consumer spending forecast to climb by 6.2% this year, after growing by 9.5% from 2015-2019.

However, Jacques Nel, the firm’s head of Africa macro research, cautions that these remarkable growth figures should be put into context. “In 2019, total consumer spending in Kenya amounted to around US$76bn. South Africa, with a population size similar to that of Kenya, recorded private consumption of around US$211bn last year,” he says.

Unlikely partners

As neither the largest nor the fastest-growing African economy – those titles are held by Nigeria and Ethiopia, respectively – and not even ranking in the top five US export markets in the continent, it is not immediately obvious why the US would choose Kenya for its first Sub-Saharan African trade deal.

“One reason for the likely US focus on Kenya lies with the heavy influence of China inside the country,” say IHS Markit analysts John Raines and William Farmer. The research firm considers Kenya to be China’s only ‘core’ Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) partner in sub-Saharan Africa, where strategic Chinese infrastructure investments are likely to be made.

Raines and Farmer also proffer that Kenya probably is seeking to re-engage with the US after it failed to secure from Chinese investors the required US$3.8bn billion in funding for stage 2B of its Standard Gauge Railway (SGR) project, first in September 2018 and again in June 2019.

For Eiser, the rationale may be more pragmatic still: “A couple of years ago, when Ambassador Lighthizer said that the US had an interest in negotiating a bilateral FTA with a country in Africa, the stated position was that the US was not going to go out and find suitors, but instead welcomed conversations with those who thought they had the potential to enter an agreement,” he says. “Quite frankly, I think there were a few countries that raised their hand with an interest, but Kenya was the one that might have raised its hand first or at least spoke loudest.”

Another blow to multilateralism?

A trade deal with a single African country also seems to fly in the face of progress made by the African Union and the nascent African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) to bring together the whole continent as one, unified trading bloc. A meeting between deputy United States Trade Representative C.J. Mahoney and African Union Commissioner for Trade and Industry Albert Muchanga last year seemed to indicate that talks might begin on a deal for US-AfCFTA trade, but it would appear that all bets are now off, with Muchanga stating to the media recently that the proposed new trade arrangement might break the terms of Kenya’s commitment to AfCFTA.

“We have provisions in the AfCFTA which require a country to notify us when it intends to enter into a free-trade agreement. Any preferences given to a third party must also be accorded to other members of the continental trade body,” he said.

If Kenya were to be found to have broken the terms of the AfCFTA, African trading partners would probably impose tariffs on imports from Kenya in retaliation, delay cargo at border crossings, and seize goods on the grounds of being substandard or smuggled, say IHS Markit’s Raines and Farmer. They add this would also increase the likelihood of other AfCFTA members breaking the terms of the agreement, including adhering to tariff liberalisation schedules.

“If anything, the US-Kenya trade agreement clearly reflects the Trump administration’s intention to move away from the multilateral approach to trade agreements to rather bilateral deals with countries in Africa, especially the fast-growing countries,” points out Vincent Phiri, economist at NKC African Economics. He says that the talks “undermine African leaders’ efforts to boost regional integration”, and put African manufacturers at risk: “US companies could almost certainly produce at lower costs and therefore offer cheaper products to local consumers, effectively crowding out local manufacturers. This will, in practice, work against the goals of AfCFTA,” he says.

For its part, the US is keen to downplay any allegations that a deal with Kenya would threaten the AfCFTA. “We believe this agreement with Kenya will complement Africa’s regional integration efforts, including in the East African Community and the landmark AfCFTA, and the US pledges its continued support to help the AfCFTA achieve its fullest potential,” says Ambassador Lighthizer, in a statement.

The US Chamber of Commerce’s Eiser agrees: “The juxtaposition of a US bilateral FTA coming in to support a broader regional approach for American investments and then overlay that with the African continental free trade area, the objective of which is to bring down trade barriers between markets, is really complementary, which is why we are supportive of both actions.”


Read related news articles

Ruto's State visit spotlights Kenya's centrality to Africa-US relations [Download Facsheet]

President Joe Biden's choice of Kenya for a first African state visit in more than 15 years is no coincidence, but both countries must be clear on what is driving this increasing strategic dependence. Kenyan President William Ruto's arrival in Washington on 22 May ends a historic drought. No African leader has made a state visit to the US since John Kufuor of Ghana in 2008 - three times longer than the previous record gap, but a period that...

23 May 2024

Senator Coons talks US and sub-Saharan African countries partnership amid Kenyan President’s visit

In case you missed it, U.S. Senator Chris Coons (D-Del.) discussed Kenyan President William Ruto’s visit to the United States this week and the need for Congress to advance a reauthorization of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) in an interview with Devex yesterday. A major area of interest for President Ruto is the trade relationship between the United States and Kenya, and his visit is expected to lend support to the...

22 May 2024

Top democrats on Senate and House committees urge Administration to upgrade Kenya trade talks to a comprehensive trade agreement

Senate Finance Committee Chair Ron Wyden, D-Ore., and House Ways and Means Committee Ranking Member Richard Neal, D-Mass., called on U.S. Trade Representative Katherine Tai to transition current trade discussions with Kenya into negotiations of a comprehensive, enforceable trade agreement, in a letter today.  Although the Biden administration is in discussions for a U.S.-Kenya Strategic Trade and Investment Partnership (STIP),...

21 May 2024

Kenya-US trade talks inching closer to completion – Cabinet Sec Miano

Kenya and the US are inching closer to reaching a trade deal, Investments, Trade and Industry CS Rebecca Miano has hinted, meaning a pact could be in place by end of this year. This, even as the US expresses confidence that the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa), set to expire next year, will be renewed to allow Sub-Sharan nations continue to enjoy preferential export terms to the US market. The in-person talks between Kenya and US...

25 April 2024

USTR releases summaries from US – Kenya Strategic Trade and Investment Partnership negotiations

Consistent with the Biden-Harris Administration’s commitment to the highest levels of transparency in trade agreement negotiations, the Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) today released summaries of texts proposed by the U.S. side on good regulatory practices, workers’ rights and protections, and a second tranche of agriculture text. Negotiations on these texts are ongoing. USTR will negotiate the workers’...

08 April 2024

US-Kenya: Ruto’s US state visit needs to navigate America’s uncertain political future

President William Ruto will visit the United States on a State Visit in May during what is likely to be one of the most turbulent US elections in memory. Barring some miracle, or catastrophe, the US presidential election will be a showdown between the same two contenders—albeit older and less energetic—as in 2020. The US presidential election in November is the most significant geopolitical risk event of 2024. Its outcome could result in...

26 February 2024

US President Biden to welcome Kenyan President Ruto to the White House in May

President Joe Biden plans to welcome Kenyan President William Ruto to the White House in May, hosting a state visit after reneging on his promise to visit Africa last year. White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said Friday that the visit set for May 23 will mark the 60th anniversary of U.S.-Kenya diplomatic relations and "celebrate a partnership that is delivering for the people" of both countries while affirming "our strategic...

18 February 2024

US keen to strengthen Kenya’s public procurement system as trade talks resume [incl. Readout]

The US plans to strengthen Kenya’s public procurement systems in what is seen as a strategy to put in place sound structures ahead of the planned trade pact. This comes as talks on the Strategic Trade and Investment Partnership (STIP) resumed last week with a meeting in Nairobi. Kenya is pushing for the deal and renewal of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) which expires next year. Washington in a statement on Tuesday said the...

07 February 2024

US officials to fast-track talks on Kenya-US Strategic Trade and Investment Partnership (STIP)

US authorities will expedite negotiations on the Kenya-US Strategic Trade and Investment Partnership (STIP) and consider extending the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) beyond its expiry next year. Prime Cabinet Secretary and Cabinet Secretary for Foreign and Diaspora Affairs Musalia Mudavadi who spoke after a meeting with US Secretary for State Mr Tony Blinken said these initiatives will facilitate expanded duty and quota-free access...

02 February 2024

Kenya, US trade talks resume in Nairobi, go for common ground

The third round of the Strategic Trade and Investment Partnership (STIP) negotiations between Kenya and the United States opened in Nairobi yesterday. Investment, Trade and Industry Cabinet Secretary Rebecca Miano said Kenya’s delegation is being led by Trade Principal Secretary Alfred K’Ombudo.  The main agenda items for the meeting which wraps up tomorrow revolve around agriculture, good regulatory practices, and workers’ rights...

30 January 2024

Kenya, US talks shift to agriculture

Kenya and the United States are set to begin talks on contentious clauses in a proposed bilateral trade deal amid fears the agreement could flood the market with cheap agricultural imports from America. The delayed third in-person round of talks will focus on agriculture, good regulatory practices and workers’ rights and protections, according to a statement from the US Trade Representative Office (USTR). The three-day negotiations...

27 January 2024

You are here: Home/News/Article/Potential US-Kenya trade pact meets with muted response