With mitumba ban in tatters, what next for trade between Kenya, US?
The East African Community had given itself up to 2019 to begin stopping the importation of second hand clothes from the United States.
In 2016, the presidents of Kenya, Burundi, Tanzania, Uganda and Rwanda said taking the move would protect their textile and leather industries.
It did not take long before things began falling apart. First, the Secondary Materials and Recycled Textiles Association, a US lobby, argued that the ban would amount to a trade barrier, violating the Africa Growth Opportunity Act (Agoa).
The Act allows no tariffs on particular goods from Africa.
Then, the US Government started issuing warnings to EAC countries: If any ban was imposed, the states would lose the privilege of selling goods to America.
Last year, Kenya pulled out of the EAC ‘mitumba’ ban deal. The then Trade Cabinet Secretary Adan Mohammed said the government was letting market forces determine what Kenyans want to buy.
TEXTILE INDUSTRY
“It is, of course, our desire to develop and promote our textile industry and create more jobs,” he said.
“Through the transition of market forces, we would like ‘mitumba’ to compete with clothes that are produced within East Africa, within Kenya. If those products are more competitive and more consumer-friendly, then you will see a reduction in the ‘mitumba’ business.”
Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda survived the suspension, but Rwanda, which went ahead with the plan, was recently removed from the Agoa beneficiaries list.
For the US, an open ‘mitumba’ market will guarantee the estimated $120 million sales into EAC. Kenya, through Agoa, has sold goods valued at $256 million (Sh25.6 billion) to the US this year, mainly clothing under this arrangement, according to the US Census Bureau.
In 2017, the trade with the US was valued at Sh126 billion, more than half of it benefiting America.
Under Agoa, Kenya sold about Sh40 billion worth of textiles and clothing to the US, while Uganda, Rwanda and Tanzania sold a cumulative Sh4.3 billion.
60,000 JOBS
In rescinding the ban, Kenyan officials argued that more than 60,000 jobs in the textile industry were under threat.
Yet President Donald Trump has always emphasised the "America First" policy when engaging with other parties and countries.
When Trump first made contact with President Uhuru Kenyatta last year, a White House read-out of the call said the two “discussed our economic partnership and mutual dedication to overcoming terrorism and other regional security challenges through close cooperation”.
Politically, the meeting between presidents Kenyatta and Trump could benefit Kenya’s image, argues Mr Benard Ayieko, an economist and commentator on trade and investment.
“It is also an opportunity for the President to engage his US counterpart on interventions that will reduce the trade imbalance. The US remains a key source of tourists to Kenya. They thus need to discuss challenges that stop Americans from arriving for holidays in droves,” he said.
MORE TRADE
Observers say Kenya will draw little if she fails to push for more trade with the US.
“We need to change gears from the tradition of selling primary commodities. Most of our exports are apparel, which are not even manufactured Kenyan companies,” Mr Clement Onyango, the director of the think-tank CUTS International, told the Nation.
“We need lots of value addition because Kenya is an agriculture-based economy. Many American firms have done this bit so well, in food processing, ICT and e-commerce. These are the areas that the President can facilitate cross-feritilisation of ideas.”
Ahead of the meeting, Foreign Affairs CS Monica Juma spoke of Africa’s engagement with the US, after Agoa expires in 2025.
ACCESS US MARKETS
Agoa was started by President George W Bush to help African countries access US markets.
But it also requires beneficiaries to eliminate trade barriers or at least show progress in doing so.
“The policy advantages of Agoa have enabled entire industries to emerge in many countries, such as textile exports in Kenya,” the minister told African diplomats in Washington on Wednesday.
“Regrettably, these Agoa policy advantages have not translated to firm-level advantages that define world beaters with the inevitable lifting of the preferences.”
According to Dr Juma, Africa can improve on that by adopting the Continental Free Trade Area agreement, signed early this year to open up markets as a way of dealing with any vacuum left with the expiry of Agoa.
Read related news articles
Kenya: 4th AmCham business summit to advocate for enhanced partnership and investment In US-East Africa trade
The fourth edition of the regional American Chamber of Commerce Kenya (AmCham) Business Summit, the premier platform for strengthening bilateral trade and investment between the United States, Kenya, and East Africa is set to be held on April 24–25, 2024, in Nairobi, Kenya. Kenya’s President William Ruto is confirmed as Chief Guest, leading a government delegation to the summit that aims to expand commercial opportunities and markets....
19 March 2024
US President Biden to welcome Kenyan President Ruto to the White House in May
President Joe Biden plans to welcome Kenyan President William Ruto to the White House in May, hosting a state visit after reneging on his promise to visit Africa last year. White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said Friday that the visit set for May 23 will mark the 60th anniversary of U.S.-Kenya diplomatic relations and "celebrate a partnership that is delivering for the people" of both countries while affirming "our strategic...
18 February 2024
'Nigeria missing as Kenya, Ghana tap AGOA opportunities to boost foreign exchange earnings'
Africa’s biggest economy is still failing to tap the opportunities that the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) present to boost its foreign exchange, amid acute dollar shortages. The AGOA has been on for over twenty-three years as it was enacted in 2020. In 2015, the program was modernised and extended to 2025, implying that there are only about 15 months before the window closes. Some countries have taken advantage of the AGOA more...
05 February 2024
Kenya-US to deepen ICT, apparel and agriculture trade
Kenya and United States are in talks to identify areas of interest in information communication technology (ICT) sector that can interest US firms. A meeting between The US Ambassador to Kenya, Megan Whitman, and the Cabinet Secretary for Investments, Trade, and Industry Rebecca Miano, the states sought cooperation in six key areas. The meeting laid the groundwork for an enhanced collaboration between Kenya and the United States in...
09 November 2023
Kenya President Ruto joins US-Kenya business roadshow in San Francisco
Kenya's President William Ruto will address leading US technology companies and investors on Friday at the US-Kenya Business Roadshow in San Francisco organised by the American government’s Prosper Africa initiative. The roadshow - also co-organised by the US Embassy in Nairobi - highlights the business and investment potential in Kenya’s booming tech sector, a statement from the US Embassy in Kenya said. The event is part of a...
15 September 2023
AGOA boosts Kenya's textile exports to US, sector sees 7.2% growth
The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) has benefitted Kenya’s textile and apparel sector, leading to monthly exports to the tune of Sh4.5 billion, or Sh150 million per day, last year, according to a study by London-based Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA). The programme has had a positive impact on the country’s export-processing zones (EPZs), especially in the textile and garment sector. Kenya is the second-largest exporter of...
08 August 2023
Kenya's president meets US delegates on trade and investments
Kenyan President William Ruto has today held talks with US Trade Representative, Ambassador Katherine Tai. The discussions were based on US trade policy. Ruto said that the country is ready to strengthen the already existing relations between the two nations. "We will stretch our ties beyond the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) in the wake of advanced technology and climate change, for the full exploitation of our trade potential,"...
19 July 2023
US trade rep in Nairobi as Kenya's solo deals worry the EAC block [incl. Readouts]
The US trade representative is in Nairobi to co-lead a meeting that seeks Kenya's partnership in a fresh trade deal. The Trade and Investment Framework Agreement (TIFA Council) is pursuing various agreements even as regional peers express concern over Kenya's solo approach. Yesterday, Trade Representative, Katherine Tai met patron circle members of the American Chamber of Commerce-Kenya (AmCham Kenya) ahead of today's...
17 July 2023
US boosts Kenya apparel industry with $55m in new trade deals
The US is giving Kenya $55 million for expansion of export processing zones in a move that will boost Nairobi’s apparel exports. US initiative Prosper Africa and the US Embassy announced the funding at the launch of the US-Kenya Business Roadshow held on April 25 in New York. The announcement was part of the commitments made by President Joe Biden at the US-Africa Leaders’ Summit last year. The funds will be channelled under USAid and...
29 April 2023
Why Africa, why Kenya? Remarks by US Ambassador to Kenya
Thank you, Scott, for the kind introduction. It is a pleasure to partner with the Prosper Africa initiative to drive investment in Kenya and countries across the African continent. I am happy to kick off our U.S.-Kenya Business Roadshow with all of you today, and to announce that we will be partnering with Prosper Africa throughout the year to engage businesses and investors in cities across the United States. Our next stops include San...
26 April 2023
Kenya-USA: Joint Statement on the third US-Kenya bilateral strategic dialogue [incl. VIDEO]
The text of the following statement was released by the Governments of the United States of America and the Kenya on the occasion of U.S.-Kenya Bilateral Strategic Dialogue in Washington, D.C. on April 24, 2023. Begin Text: The Governments of the United States of America and the Republic of Kenya held the third iteration of the U.S.-Kenya Bilateral Strategic Dialogue in Washington, D.C. on April 24, 2023. The U.S.-Kenya Strategic...
24 April 2023